A few impressive demonstrations do not show how an AI workflow will behave on ordinary work. A useful evaluation set includes the inputs the team actually expects, the cases that require caution, and examples where the system should decline to produce a confident answer.
Define the task before collecting examples
Choose one output and one operating context. For instance, a pilot might draft a short internal summary from an approved service request. That is narrower than “help with operations” and makes review more consistent.
Use permissioned, minimized, or synthetic examples as appropriate. Remove personal information that is unnecessary for the test. Keep the test set in an approved location rather than pasting a collection of customer records into an unreviewed tool.
Include the awkward inputs
Add missing details, contradictory statements, unusual terminology, and information outside the task's scope. For a hypothetical inquiry summary, include a request with no date, one with two different locations, and one that quotes a previous conversation. Decide what a good output should preserve or flag.
Write the expected qualities before running the test. A reviewer needs to know which facts must remain accurate, what may be omitted, and which unsupported conclusions are unacceptable. Avoid changing the criteria simply because the output sounds polished.
Keep a separate check for later changes
Do not use every example while tuning the workflow. Hold back some representative cases for a later check, and refresh the collection when real work reveals a new failure mode. Record the prompt, model or configuration version, and review result together.
A small, carefully chosen set can expose concrete weaknesses, but it cannot prove universal reliability. Use it to decide whether the bounded pilot is ready for its next stage. The first deliverable is a reviewable test collection, not a claim that the AI has been validated for every situation.

