VANKPA
Start a project

AI & automation

Use reviewer disagreement to improve an AI pilot.

Investigate differences between human reviewers before treating a single approval label as reliable ground truth.

Illustrated scene: Three reviewers compare colored assessment cards around a wooden table.

Human review improves an AI workflow only when reviewers understand what they are judging. If two people apply different standards, the pilot can appear inconsistent even when the generated output is unchanged. Disagreement is evidence about the review process as well as the model.

Make the criteria observable

Define which facts must be accurate, what the output must include, and what would make it unsuitable. Replace a broad label such as “good answer” with decisions the reviewers can explain. Separate style preferences from errors that change meaning or create an unsupported commitment.

For a hypothetical customer-email drafting pilot, one reviewer may prefer a warm introduction while another prefers a direct opening. That difference should not be scored the same as inventing a delivery date.

Compare a small shared sample

Have reviewers independently assess the same safe examples, then discuss the differences. Look for unclear instructions, missing business context, or legitimate judgment calls. Do not pressure people to agree simply to improve a headline score.

Where the answer depends on policy or scope, ask the responsible owner to clarify the underlying rule. An evaluation rubric cannot resolve a business decision that has never been made.

Preserve meaningful exceptions

Some requests will remain ambiguous. Give reviewers a way to mark “needs clarification” rather than forcing every output into acceptable or unacceptable. Record the reason so future examples can test the same issue.

Repeat the shared-sample check after major changes or when new reviewers join. Keep the exercise proportionate to the task's risks and volume.

The immediate result may be a clearer review guide rather than a different AI configuration. That is useful progress. A pilot becomes easier to evaluate when the people supervising it can explain what they agree on, where judgment remains, and who decides when the criteria conflict.

Plan your next step.

Explore the related serviceDiscuss your project
Help me choose