A popup can attract attention while making the website less useful. Someone trying to check service coverage or send an inquiry may have to dismiss a promotion before continuing. The business then measures the popup's clicks without noticing the task it interrupted.
Define why an interruption is necessary
Ask whether the message is urgent, relevant to the current page, and difficult to communicate another way. A temporary service closure may deserve prominence. A general newsletter invitation can often sit within the page without blocking anything.
Consider a hypothetical customer opening a service page from a phone. If a promotion covers the contact option and another banner covers the bottom of the screen, little useful content remains. Test the combined experience, not each overlay in isolation.
Make dismissal reliable
Any overlay should have a clearly labeled close action, usable keyboard behavior, and a sensible path back to the original task. Do not disguise an advertisement as a system warning or make the decline option insulting. Avoid repeatedly showing the same interruption after a visitor has dismissed it.
Check whether the content still works when scripts fail or browser storage is restricted. A broken overlay should not leave the page inaccessible. If the overlay collects information, explain its purpose and use only the fields required.
Judge the full journey
Compare the intended benefit with completion of the page's main task. Newsletter signups do not automatically justify making project inquiries harder. Use consent-appropriate measurement and direct observation rather than assuming that every click represents a positive experience.
Start by removing an unnecessary interruption from one important page and reviewing what changes. Where a message genuinely needs emphasis, try a clear inline notice first. Attention is useful when it helps the customer act, not merely when it can be counted.

